-
Coming this Month: Chisels with a Replaceable Tip
This is, as far as I know, a first. This month M. Power Tools will introduce new chisels
that have a replaceable high-speed-steel tip. According to the company's literature,
you should be able to change from a dull tip to a sharp one in less than a minute
using only a screwdriver.
And to make things even more interesting, M. Power is going to produce chisel tips
in different profiles, including a standard bevel, a tip with a serrated edge and
a most unusual three-sided cutter (the two edges and the bevel will be sharp).
The tips come completely sharp and are resharpenable. That means that you can replace
the tip in the middle of a project (or while on a job) and then sharpen the dull tip
at your leisure. Of course, some woodworkers will simply toss the dull tip – like
some woodworkers toss dull chisels.
The mechanism that holds the tips uses screws that will stay attached to the chisel's
blade, so you won't lose the screws on your shop floor.
The tips are titanium-plated high-speed steel (HSS) which has been hardened to Rockwell
63 on the "C" scale, which means they will be fairly tough. I've worked with Japanese
high-speed steel chisels that were designed for carpentry. They can take a beating.
M Power officials say the high-speed steel will last up to five times longer, though
I didn't see that level of durability in the Japanese HSS chisels I tested a few years
ago.
The company will offer two sorts of chisel handles. The MercPRO version has a blue
acetate handle with a steel strike in the handle. The Fleetwood Innovator version
has a beech handle with a brass ferrule and a steel strike as well.
Both version are made in England, according to the company.
These tools should be available in the United States by Sept. 17 and will be available
through Eagle America and Garrett Wade.
The retail prices of the Innovator version of the chisel are as follows:
• 1/2" will be $47.85
• 3/4" will be $49.50
• 1" will be $52.50
• Cutter inserts will range from $7.49 to $9.95 each
When these tools become available we'll give you a full report.
— Christopher Schwarz
Other Interesting Tools With Replaceable Inserts
• Heard of Rali planes? These interesting Swiss-made tools have been around for along
time and use replaceable plane irons. Some woodworkers swear by them. Take a look
at then at Advanced
Machinery.
• Stanley had a line of handplanes with replaceable blades. Called "Ready-Edge Blades,"
these tools are quite similar to the M Power idea. You can read the original patent here.
• Or if you want to learn how to sharpen, I recommend our book "Handtool Essentials,"
which is a collection of our best writing on hand tools from all our contributors,
from Lonnie Bird to David Charlesworth to Adam Cherubini. It's available in
our store for just $15.
-
Vote for your Favorite WIA T-shirt Slogan
We've narrowed down the entries for our contest to pick a T-shirt slogan for our Woodworking
in America event. The front side of the shirt will say: "Woodworking in America 2010."
And the back will have a slogan.
Pick your favorite slogan using the poll below, but do it fast – we're choosing the
winner on Wednesday, Sept. 8.
-
What I Think About Sawplate Thickness
Now that there are so many sawmakers out there, it's no surprise that they are all
trying to offer something a little different than the rock-solid Independence dovetail
saw that kicked off this revolution in Western sawmaking.
In the last decade, toolmakers have again begun experimenting with different:
• Tooth filings, including changing the rake, pitch and fleam.
• Hang angles (how the grip is angled compared to the toothline)
• Different backs – traditional bent backs, slotted solid backs, backs that taper
in width
• Different widths of sawplate, including those that get narrower at the toe.
• Different thicknesses of the sawplate.
All of these differences change how the saw cuts. And little things add up to significant
changes. For example: relax the rake a tad, lower the hang angle a few degrees and
add some fleam and you'll get a saw that is remarkably smooth-cutting but is fairly
slow. The important point here is that I think saws are subtle and personal tools,
much more so than handplanes.
So it's difficult for me to talk about one of these factors in isolation. But I'm
going to try.
I get a lot of questions about sawplate thickness and if it's better to have a plate
that is really thin (such as .015") or fairly thick (I have one on my desk that is
.027"). The answer is, as Mike Dunbar at The
Windsor Institute is wont to say: It depends.
Let's take a look at the Lie-Nielsen line of dovetail saws because the company has
three saws, each with different characteristics. There is the company's standard line,
which has 15 points per inch (ppi) and a plate that is .020" thick – fairly standard
stuff among many sawmakers. The company makes a progressive-pitch dovetail saw with
a .020" plate – the saw starts at 16 ppi at the toe and ends at 9 ppi at the heel.
And the company offers a thin-plate dovetail saw with 15 ppi and a .015"-thick plate.
If you were in the showroom in Warren, Maine, and were trying to choose a saw, which
tool should you buy? It depends on your work and your level of experience.
The standard dovetail saw is an excellent tool for all-around work. The plate is robust
and hard to kink. The tooth configuration makes it a fine saw for dovetailing carcases
and drawers.
The progressive-pitch saw is just as easy to start as the standard saw, but it is
swifter, especially in thick stock. If most of your work is dovetailing carcases or
you work in stock that is thicker than 3/4", this saw makes a lot of sense. The big
teeth at the heel are a little big for dovetailing thin drawer sides. Sometimes the
heel will catch in stock thinner than 1/2".
Then there is the thin-kerf saw. It is swift like the progressive-pitch saw (because
it removes less wood). And its tooth configuration make it ideal for 3/4" carcases
or 1/2" drawer sides. The trade-off is that the plate is more easily kinked.
When I teach sawing, I let students use all of my saws (except one) during a class.
And in May, I had a student kink my Lie-Nielsen thin-kerf saw at the heel. I've been
too embarrassed to send it back, though I guess I'll have to get over that.
But the experience taught me a good lesson: Thin plates are not for beginners.
So if you are a beginner, I recommend a saw with a more robust plate. Get the standard
saw if you plan to do drawers and carcases. Get the progressive pitch if you tend
to work in thicker stock or plan to do more carcases than drawers.
And get the thin kerf if you are an experienced sawyer.
Once you choose your saw, you might need to change another tool in your shop as well.
If you remove the waste between your pins and tails with a saw (I do), then plate
thickness comes into play.
A jeweler's saw equipped with scrollsaw blades will work with any dovetail saw. The
downside to jeweler's saws is that the blades tend to break easily. Too easily in
my book.
A coping saw has blades that almost never break, but they are thicker. My Olson sawblades
(available from Tools for Working Wood) make a kerf about .024" in width. They fit
fine in a kerf left by a standard .020" dovetail saw, but it's a squeeze for them
to get into a kerf left by a thin plate. Note that home center coping saw blades are
even thicker than the Olsons, and they are over-set. So they may not work at all.
— Christopher Schwarz
Other Sawing Resources
• Lie-Nielsen has just released my DVD "Sawing
Fundamentals" – it discusses how to choose the right saw for your work and how
to use it with precision. All my proceeds from the DVD are donated to help restore
the White Water Shaker Village.
• Need a saw education? One good place to get lost is the Disstonian Institute. disstonianinstitute.com.
-
The Six-board, $100 Workbench
At long last, Megan Fitzpatrick (shown actual size in the photo above) and I began
work on a new workbench for Woodworking in America. We're building this one from Eastern
white pine timber left over from a log cabin that was built 10 years ago.
These six hunks of pine were kiln-dried then sat in a covered shed, where they checked
a bit, gathered a bunch of spiderwebs and became covered in dirt.
Megan (who is really quite tiny as you can see in the photo above), snagged the entire
lot for $100 after spotting an ad on Craigslist.com.
After bringing these boards into the shop and running some of them down to experiment
with the material, I've become convinced that log home supplies might just be an excellent
source of lumber for a workbench.
This week I chatted with a salesman from Discount
Log Home Supplies in East Canton, Ohio, about getting some prices for "cants,"
which are squared-off timbers. This company sells several species, though the Ohio
yard stocks Eastern White Pine, which has been kiln dried to 11-15 percent. It comes
rough-sawn and is basically No. 2 common.
After some calculations, I figure than an 8' Roubo-style bench would require about
104 board feet of 5" x 5" x 8' boards, plus about 21 board feet for waste. The company
charges 85 cents a board foot plus the trucking charge ($1.75 a loaded mile).
In the end, it would cost us about $160 to $170 for the material for a single bench.
That is not bad, considering that the top will be made of four pieces and there are
no other glue-ups.
I was so encouraged by this that I asked Kelly Mehler at the Kelly
Mehler School of Woodworking if I could teach a workbench class in 2011 using
these massive timbers as the raw material.
And I think he's game.
Today Megan (my foul-mouthed featherboard) and I sliced into the material after tuning
up our massive Grizzly band saw (a fine bear it is!) and knocking down the six slabs
into manageable pieces that we could wrestle through the bear.
As the dirt, spiderwebs and checks dropped away, Megan and I could only "ooh" and
"aah" at this beautiful and massive material. This is going to be a fine-looking bench.
More details tomorrow. Now I need a massage.
— Christopher Schwarz
Other Workbench and Vise Resources
• You can pre-order my new book on workbenches titled " The
Workbench Design Book," which features a French design much like the one we're
building here. If you order it now, you'll save 20 percent. Here's the
link to our store.
• Benchcrafted has
a new version of its awesome tail vise. Plus new instructions you can download from
the company's site.
 
-
Sindelar's Traveling Tool Collection Coming to WIA
One of the world's biggest tool collectors is bringing his brand-new traveling tool
museum to Northern Kentucky on Oct. 1-2 to show it off to the public at the Woodworking
in America event at the Northern Kentucky Convention Center.
John Sindelar of Edwardsburg, Mich., has spent his entire adult life amassing some
of the world's rarest, most expensive and beautiful tools. And this year Sindelar
built a traveling tool museum that will travel the country to share some of the highlights
of his collection at festivals and fairs.
Even if you got shut out of the classes at Woodworking in America this year, the Marketplace
itself is well worth the trip (and it's only $7 for two days).
Sindelar's traveling collection includes more than 500 items (valued at $300,000)
from all the trades, from woodworking to blacksmithing to household tools. Visitors
can see one of the first axes ever made in the New World, according to archaeologists
(it's copper!), specialized plow planes made entirely of ivory, antique levels from
Asia and much more.
"You name it, we have it," Sindelar says. "From the beginning of time to the present
day."
The traveling collection is housed in a custom-built trailer that Sindelar's woodworking
business outfitted to look like the inside of a vintage luxury locomotive car. The
interior is constructed entirely with antiqued frame-and-panel in cherry – and features
a tool in the center of each panel.
The 30'-long, 220-square-foot traveling museum is Sindelar's effort to build support
for a permanent tool museum for his enormous tool collection now housed in his shop
in Michigan.
The traveling tool museum will be parked on the floor of the Marketplace at Woodworking
in America at the Northern Kentucky Convention Center. Admission to the Marketplace
(just $7) gets you in to see the traveling tool museum, plus more than 70 woodworking
vendors and demonstrators showing off all aspects of woodworking with both hand and
power tools.
— Christopher Schwarz
P.S. I'll have photos of the traveling tool museum later this week.
More Links to Obscenely Gorgeous Tools
• For more information on Sindelar's collection, visit his web site at: sindelartoolmuseum.com
• Read (for free) a
story I wrote where I test-drove some of the world's most expensive planes.
• "Tools Rare and Ingenious" by Sandor Nagyszalanczy has some serious brass and steel.
• My book, "Handplane
Essentials," has a lot of stories about modern makers, including Konrad Sauer,
Ron Brese, Karl Holtey, Bill Carter, Wayne Anderson, D.L. Barrett & Sons and more.
It's available from our bookstore.
• View a free
slideshow of my trip to Sindelar's tool museum a few years ago.
|